How I learned to stop feeling hopeless about money
J.D.’s note: Last week’s talk by Vicki Robin was hosted by the School of Financial Freedom, a Portland-based organization I’m friendly with. At that talk, I met Naomi Veak, one of the school’s coaches. She and I have a lot in common (grew up poor in small towns, attended the same college, etc.). I asked if she’d share her story with Get Rich Slowly readers. She agreed.
Have you ever thought how different your life could have been if you’d taken someone’s advice? What if I told you it may not be too late?
I recently rediscovered a letter my mother wrote to me when I was 19, attending a small liberal arts college in another state.
Towards the end of the letter, she told me to save it, so I did — even though reading it left me angry and frustrated, and not a single word sunk in. You see, she was giving me financial advice after another tear-filled plea for money.
“Don’t expect your thinking to change overnight,” she wrote. “Give yourself time to feel the inward peace of mind that will eventually come.”
This “inward peace of mind” took me 25 years to achieve! How did I finally get there? My name is Naomi Veak, and this is my story.
A Poor Girl at a Rich School
I was a poor girl at a rich kid school.
It was a school I couldn’t afford, and I was surrounded by lifestyles I was ashamed that I couldn’t pay for.
This was only the beginning of a long struggle with finances, where the same money scripts — unconscious beliefs about money that drive our behavior — played themselves out again and again. (For more about this idea, see J.D.’s article about how your money blueprint shapes your world.)
I wanted money. I just couldn’t hold onto it.
Shortly after college, I became homeless. One friend after another was put to the test when I crashed on their couch for too long.
A year later, my boyfriend and I were living out of his truck on the cold and rainy Oregon coast. I remember sitting in the cab, crying as I counted our last handful of change. He later wrote about stealing a sandwich to split with me in a short essay he titled “Desperation and a BLT”.
Overwhelmed by credit card debt, I made an appointment at a debt settlement company to help me get things under control…only to continue charging to the same account a couple of months later.
Then my student loan debt doubled when I returned to school for another degree.
I was unhappy and embarrassed, yet I felt powerless. I wasn’t connecting my decisions with the dire situations I found myself in. Hard-working, smart people can do dumb things. It happens all of the time. (J.D. and I find it interesting that we shared the same experience at the same school only a few years apart.)
I strive to excel at just about everything I do. Being a failure at financial management was incongruous with my self-image, but also somehow felt inevitable.
Finding Financial Freedom
I’ve had three adult careers so far:
- Fine dining restaurant server. All my earnings disappeared on vacations.
- Middle-school math teacher. I thought if I worked hard enough at my job, somehow I’d magically be taken care of.
- A position at an education technology company. This came with a bigger salary — but I matched it with bigger spending.
Each of these jobs left me with the same net result, and the same underlying feelings of insecurity and inferiority from my internalized money scripts — the ones that kept me living ”money in/money out” no matter how much came in. I didn’t know another way to do it.
Then I took the Financial Freedom course from the School of Financial Freedom. It changed my life.
As I worked through the self-paced assignments along with a cohort of learners, I felt like the fog was lifting from my brain. Many nights I could hardly wait to get dinner dishes cleared so I could work on the class.
Since taking the Financial Freedom course, I’ve completely changed my spending habits. But it feels like I have more, not less.
- Within weeks, we’d built an emergency fund and paid off my husband’s student loan.
- When I attended yet another financial advisor’s presentation at work, I finally understood what she was saying!
- And after all those years of shame, I have enough self-compassion to share my financial history with you.
Why couldn’t I have just read a book or learned some of this on my own? Some people can, of course. But I needed something different. I needed a class. I needed the structure, the accountability, the social aspect of learning, and I needed to start working from the inside-out.
Since taking Financial Freedom 1, I’ve also completed Financial Freedom 2, which covers more advanced topics. I’ve also started working to boost my financial literacy in my spare time. Because of that one course, I want to find financial freedom by reading and taking in all sorts of information about money.
Mother Knows Best
What was my mother trying to tell me all those years ago?
Not long after taking the Financial Freedom course, I rediscovered my mother’s letter in a box of photos. I read her words in disbelief. This is what she was trying to tell me when I was in college?
It all makes so much more sense to me now.
- “Naomi, don’t let yourself lose ground financially. Work with the system. It’s not going to change just because you want it to.”
- “The sooner you learn that happiness is not derived from material possessions, but other values, the happier you will be.”
- “How often do you think about all you have to be grateful for?”
- “Learning a new value system may be one of the most valuable lessons you learn in your college years.”
- “Don’t expect your thinking to change overnight. Give yourself time to feel the inward peace of mind that will eventually come…”
- “Eventually you will adapt and you will be happier for it.”
- “The happiest people make money work for them.”
- “Remember money is for a protection.”
- “Don’t let material possessions control your life.”
- “You are extremely intelligent and have a determined nature when you think something is important. Use these assets to gain control.”
My mother was right, of course. My money scripts weren’t an excuse to continue a destructive behavior pattern. Now that I understand myself, and have learned an entirely new way of thinking about and behaving with money, I’ve been able to change.
The happiest people make money work for them. We do have to learn to work within the system; it won’t change just because we want it to. Learning a new value system is one of the most valuable lessons I’m learning. It just didn’t happen for me 25 years ago.
Become A Money Boss And Join 15,000 Others
Subscribe to the GRS Insider (FREE) and we’ll give you a copy of the Money Boss Manifesto (also FREE)
There are 6 comments to "How I learned to stop feeling hopeless about money".
I’ve been sharing comments with Naomi by email, but I feel compared to share some of this publicly.
When I first read this piece, I had no idea that she and I had attended the same university. When we figured that out, I was surprised. We come from similar backgrounds (poor kids from small, rural towns), attended the same university and shared similar experiences (feelings of shame for not being able to afford what other kids could afford), then struggled with money after we left college. Eventually, we both found financial freedom, but the path wasn’t easy.
Reading about the letter from Naomi’s mind reminded me that my own father sent me a similar letter. I shared it here at GRS in 2008. I’ll re-publish it this Friday or Saturday.
Finally: In case you all haven’t noticed over the past couple of months, I very much support what the School of Financial Freedom is trying to accomplish. Last year, I worked with its founder (Douglas Tsoi) to create a joint three-hour workshop here in Portland. It was a great experience. I find myself in full agreement with the stuff he teaches. As a result, I’m happy to promote his efforts (and the school’s efforts) here on the blog. I’ll be mentioning the school and its courses much more in the future because I truly believe they can help people improve their relationship with money.
Great post. Thanks for sharing Naomi & JD. I like how we bounce from February budgets to heady stuff like this. Good balance.
Doesn’t it seem like money management (along with parenting, etc.) falls in that unnamed category of life experiences that, no matter how much literature exists on the topic*, or how much advice you get from friends and family, every single person has to reinvent the wheel for themselves, to an extent? Plus, proficiency in other aspects of life doesn’t always cross-over (like Naomi said, proficiency in other aspects of life make difficulties here MORE frustrating).
I think that’s why personal finance is so fascinating. Circumstances vary so widely that universal advice is hard to come by. Its the sort of high-stakes challenge that will always be interesting to humans because there is no universal solution.
*I’m just now reading “Your Money or Your Life” and I think one of the reasons this book is so revered is how specific and detailed the program is. The variety of examples is exhaustive and its applicability is clear and obvious.
Agreed, it seems some people go their whole lives and never get to have the revelation Naomi had, despite all the help available. The idea that the system is against them and they have no control is so ingrained. I really hope that financial education becomes much more common at all stages of life. I can’t think how else to prevent people slipping into that trap.
I’ve read a ton of PF books over the years, but my greatest mental liberator was reading Thomas Sowell’s “Basic Economics”. Which is actually not a personal finance book, but provides a good picture of reality.
Once you accept that scarcity is a fact of nature and that you must decide on the allocation of limited resources which have alternative uses, reality opens up with great clarity.
Part of the problem many of us have is that we don’t recognize this essential fact, and we believe unconsciously in things like “the world should have unlimited resources” and “I deserve to have everything I desire,” and all manner of wishful thinking.
And then reality does not match our wishes, of course, and paffffff!
Hope is the belief that some sort of salvation lies in the future somewhere. Which is fine I guess and helps keep a good attitude through tough times.
But acceptance of economic reality “saves” one *now* and allows one to make smart decisions *now*. Instead of waiting for the future, one can feel the daily accrual of copound interest. The gradual achievement of goals is a great mood booster. There is satisfaction in the struggle.
And yet the acceptance of scarcity as a fact of life is the hardest thing for some people. It’s often an ideological thing.
I have friends who are deeply in debt and going ever deeper, they start coplaining, and then get angry with me when I point out the essential fact that you can’t have your cake and eat it too.
Makes for hilarious party conversation, haaa haaa haaa…
Anyway I just wanted to share that book title. It’s not a perfect book but it drives home some basic facts about reality. Understanding is liberating.
I’ve heard great things about Basic Economics. I started it and it was good, but a bit TOO basic for me (I’ve always been a numbers person and didnt have the mental block you describe) I think he wrote a follow on as well that I put on my reading list, but haven’t gotten to…
What I didnt understand was the phrase “have your cake and eat it too”. I never understood how you were expected to eat cake you didn’t have, or the purpose of having cake you didn’t eat. I had to have someone explain it to me.
I believe that Financial Independence is a continuum of change from the standard in debt American consumer, to a savvy, frugal, and empowered individual with a budget, savings, investments and goals. Like any behavioral change it is hard. Often we give good advice like your mom’s from this article but at the wrong time. It is important to give and to seek advice that gets you to the next stage on that continuum so that it resonates rather than idolizing some guy on a yacht when you have six figures of student debt. Before I became financially independent it seemed like there was some secret that I didn’t understand. Now it feels obvious. Being in my 30’s and now suddenly not needing to work I try to help others. I commend this post for doing the same and am hopeful that the course offered is a reasonable cost benefit for those who may attend.